Appendices

Supplementary data

Technological parameter assumptions

Energy supply technologies

Parameter assumptions on power generation technologies (US$ kW-1). Ranges represent the differences among the regions, which are derived from IEA estimates.
  Initial cost       O&M cost      
  2020 2030 2040 2050 2020 2030 2040 2050
Coal-PC 600-2100 600-2100 600-2100 600-2100 20-55 20-55 20-55 20-55
Coal-USC 800-2600 800-2600 800-2600 800-2600 30-80 30-80 30-80 30-80
Coal-IGCC 1100-2900 1000-2750 950-2725 900-2700 50-100 45-95 42-95 40-95
Coal-IGFC 1216-3205 1105-3039 1050-3012 995-2984 56-111 50-106 47-106 45-106
Coal-IGCC CCS 3650-6250 3300-5800 2975-5450 2650-5100 165-220 150-205 135-192 120-180
Coal-IGFC CCS 4034-6908 3647-6411 3288-6024 2929-5637 184-245 167-228 150-214 134-200
Gas-GT 504-990 504-990 504-990 504-990 18-27 18-27 18-27 18-27
Gas-CC 560-1100 560-1100 560-1100 560-1100 20-30 20-30 20-30 20-30
Gas-ACC 648-1272 648-1272 648-1272 648-1272 23-35 23-35 23-35 23-35
Gas-MACC 788-1547 788-1547 788-1547 788-1547 30-45 30-45 30-45 30-45
Gas-GTFC 910-1788 910-1788 910-1788 910-1788 35-52 35-52 35-52 35-52
Gas-CC CCS 2200-3200 1850-2750 1675-2575 1500-2400 70-100 60-85 55-78 50-70
Gas-FC CCS 2111-3070 1775-2639 1607-2471 1439-2303 81-116 70-99 64-90 58-81
Oil 930-1826 930-1826 930-1826 930-1826 35-52 35-52 35-52 35-52
Nuclear 2800-6600 2750-5100 2625-4800 2500-4500 120-225 120-225 120-225 120-225
Hydrogen 1000-1000 1000-1000 1000-1000 1000-1000 25-25 25-25 25-25 25-25
Hydropower-Large 1600-2700 1700-2700 1725-2700 1750-2700 40-65 40-65 40-65 40-65
Hydropower-Small 2000-4050 2100-4050 2125-4050 2150-4050 40-80 40-80 42-80 45-80
Geothermal 2150-3600 2100-3450 2025-3325 1950-3200 45-70 40-70 40-68 40-65
Biomass 1600-2500 1550-2450 1325-2400 1100-2350 55-85 55-85 48-85 40-85
Biomass CCS 4150-5850 3850-5450 3350-5025 2850-4650 145-200 135-190 118-175 100-165
Solar PV centralized 600-1830 380-1250 325-1110 270-970 10-28 10-26 10-25 10-24
Solar PV decentralized 650-3430 410-2220 350-1935 290-1650 10-52 10-46 10-45 10-44
CSP 4900-6500 4200-5750 3725-5125 3250-4500 200-260 170-230 150-205 130-180
Wind-Onshore 1040-3190 1020-2980 1010-2915 1000-2850 26-80 26-76 26-75 26-74
Wind-Offshore fixed 2960-4960 1860-3080 1570-2670 1280-2260 65-130 50-95 45-82 40-70
Wind-Offshore floating 4440-7440 2790-4620 2355-4005 1920-3390 98-195 75-142 68-124 60-105
Parameter assumption on production of hydrogen energy carriers
    Initial cost (US$ kW-1) O&M costs (US$ kW-1) Conversion efficiency (–)
Hydrogen Electrolysis 1014 15 69%
  Coal 2670 134 60%
  Coal with CCS 2780 139 58%
  Gas 910 33 76%
  Gas with CCS 1360 41 69%
  Biomass 2333 222 60%
  Biomass with CCS 3091 290 55%
  Imported synthetic methane 910 33 76%
  Imported ammonia 1 306 12 84%
Ammonia 1 Electrolysis 855 13 53%
  Coal 2175 109 48%
  Coal with CCS 2810 141 48%
  Gas 905 23 49%
  Gas with CCS 1260 32 49%
  Biomass 6320 316 41%
  Biomass with CCS 8165 408 41%
Synthetic hydrocarbons Synthetic fuel 760 30 73%
  Synthetic methane 735 30 77%

1 Cost unit is presented in US$/t-NH3.

Solar and wind power potential

Potential for solar and wind power in 2050 (EJ yr-1)
Region Centralized PV Decentralized PV Offshore wind, fixed Offshore wind, floating Onshore wind
ARG 50.84 0.37 4.65 45.51 30.58
AUS 124.95 0.71 16.79 114.88 71.93
BRA 92.87 1.76 9.57 64.96 20.55
CAN 47.03 0.36 9.71 154.17 58.83
CHN 115.05 7.16 14.51 22.47 40.79
IDN 6.27 2.21 7.67 22.87 0.59
IND 28.4 8.18 2.66 25.63 14.83
JPN 0.89 0.84 0.64 60.25 1.1
KOR 0.47 0.35 1.29 13.59 0.58
MEX 28.42 0.97 4.41 27.21 6.54
MYS 0.89 0.35 0 0 0
NZL 2.49 0.11 0.61 64.49 1.63
RUS 78.09 0.8 59.36 186.87 88.76
THA 3.6 0.66 0 0 0.72
TUR 11.97 0.58 0.06 4.76 3.28
USA 96.4 3.89 10.17 72.75 71.89
VNM 2.46 0.83 4.42 10.66 0.56
XAF 326.07 6.19 3.92 134.12 94.19
XCS 56.04 0.61 2.24 2.65 37.4
XE10 3.58 0.62 1.58 6.28 6.56
XE15 21.07 3.87 18.57 128.01 21.78
XE3 2.68 0.3 0.27 3.34 2
XEA 20.17 0.35 1.4 14.62 10.56
XEEI 4.59 0.29 1.44 3.45 10.46
XENI 3.86 0.32 0.09 2.26 1.11
XEWI 2.2 0.14 0.7 65.79 2.34
XLM 64.77 1.88 15.25 294.1 12.4
XME 50.69 2.89 0.66 20.59 12.33
XNF 51.71 1.2 1.5 39.38 22.09
XOC 1.16 0.06 3.26 64.22 0.58
XSA 21.92 2.4 1.13 15.21 3.23
XSE 8.04 1.86 0.2 17.26 1
ZAF 29.2 0.27 0.25 39.03 12.18
Land suitability factor on centralized solar PV and onshore wind
Land category Solar PV Wind
Water bodies 0 0
Evergreen Needleleaf Forests 0 0.02
Evergreen Broadleaf Forests 0 0.02
Deciduous Needleleaf Forests 0 0.02
Deciduous Broadleaf Forests 0 0.02
Mixed Forests 0 0.02
Closed Shrublands 0 0.02
Open Shrublands 0.02 0.2
Woody Savannas 0.02 0.2
Savannas 0.02 0.2
Grasslands 0.03 0.2
Permanent Wetlands 0 0
Croplands 0.01 0.3
Urban and Built-up Lands 0 0
Cropland/Natural Vegetation Mo-saics 0 0.2
Permanent Snow and Ice 0 0
Barren 0.01 0.05

Traditional biomass share

Regression results for traditional biomass share. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Region codes denote the dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -2.8 -25.16 (***)
PPPP -0.05 -9.58 (***)
AUS 3.04 11.84 (***)
BRA 2.75 24.86 (***)
CAN 2.51 11.29 (***)
IDN 4.26 38.04 (***)
IND 4.25 40.44 (***)
JPN -3.67 -23.59 (***)
KOR -1.41 -8.33 (***)
MEX 3.03 24.1 (***)
NZL 2.31 4.77 (***)
RUS -0.47 -3.95 (***)
THA 3.9 26.7 (***)
TUR 2.65 18.34 (***)
USA 2.05 10.06 (***)
VNM 4.17 28.92 (***)
XAF 6.33 57.6 (***)
XE10 2.03 14.22 (***)
XE15 2.47 15.91 (***)
XE3 2.59 13.95 (***)
XENI 1.84 10.12 (***)
XNF 1.37 11.55 (***)
XOC 4.94 15.13 (***)
XSA 4.38 38.54 (***)
XSE 4.68 38.41 (***)
ZAF 3.03 18.64 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.977

Energy demand technologies

Technological parameter assumptions on steel sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Energy saving (MJ/*) Unit (*)
  2010 2030 2050      
Coke oven, efficient 16 16 16 30 0 t-coke
Coke oven, high efficient 41 41 41 30 1 t-coke
COG latent heat recovery 8 8 8 30 0 t-coke
CDQ 78 78 78 30 1 t-coke
Sintering furnace, efficient 1 1 1 30 0 t-steel
Sintering furnace, high-efficient 40 40 40 30 1 t-steel
Blast furnace 0 0 0 30 0 t-steel
Blast furnace w/CCS 433 433 433 30 -3 t-steel
BFG recovery 15 15 15 30 4 t-steel
TRT 21 21 21 30 0 t-steel
TRT, more efficient 26 26 26 30 0 t-steel
BOG recovery 2 2 2 30 1 t-steel
BOG latent heat recovery 27 27 27 30 0 t-steel
EAF, scrap pre-heating 7 7 7 30 0 t-steel
EAF, efficient 60 60 60 30 -0 t-steel
Continuous casting, efficient 24 24 24 30 1 t-steel
Continuous casting, more efficient 59 59 59 30 1 t-steel
Hydrogen DRI 855 855 855 30 11 t-steel

Note: Cost unit is US$ * -1. Asterisk refers to the technology specific unit. Initial costs are represented as additional cost relative to the reference technology, excluding Hydrogen-DRI. For Hydrogen-DRI, energy consumption is shown at the energy saving column. For blast furnace with CCS, energy saving is provided with negative number, as it consumes additional energy for CO2 capture.

Technological parameter assumptions on cement sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Energy saving (MJ/*) Unit (*)
  2010 2030 2050      
Vertical mill 5 5 5 30 0 t-cement
SP/NSP 2 2 2 30 3 t-cement
Cement kiln w/CCS 78 78 78 30 1 t-cement
Vertical fuel mill 5 5 5 30 0 t-cement

Note: Cost unit is US$ * -1. Asterisk refers to the technology specific unit.

Technological parameter assumptions on other industry sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Efficiency
  2010 2030 2050    
Boiler, fossil, existing 140 140 140 20 0.36
Boiler, fossil, Lv1 145 145 145 20 0.4
Boiler, fossil, Lv2 155 155 155 20 0.41
Boiler, fossil, Lv3 165 165 165 20 0.51
Boiler, fossil, Lv4 185 185 185 20 0.55
Boiler, fossil, Lv5 215 215 215 20 0.62
Boiler, biomass 173 173 173 20 0.49
Boiler, electric heating 126 126 126 20 0.9
Industrial HP Lv1 370 370 370 20 3
Industrial HP Lv2 370 370 370 20 3.6
Boiler, district heating 173 173 173 20 0.8
Boiler, hydrogen 173 173 173 20 0.7
Boiler, ammonia 173 173 173 20 0.7
Furnace, fossil, existing 204 204 204 30 0.7
Furnace, fossil, advanced 213 213 213 30 0.8
Furnace, fossil, with CCS 229 229 229 30 0.73
Furnace, biomass 163 163 163 30 0.8
Furnace, electricity 154 154 154 30 0.9
Furnace, district heat 163 163 163 30 0.8
Furnace, hydrogen 163 163 163 30 0.8
Furnace, ammonia 163 163 163 30 0.8
Power electronics, electricity, existing 9 9 9 20 0.8
Power electronics, electricity, advanced 14 14 14 20 0.84
Power electronics, electricity, w/ inverter 52 52 52 20 0.99
Power electronics, fossil, existing 9 9 9 20 0.5
Power electronics, biomass, existing 9 9 9 20 0.5
Power electronics, heat, existing 9 9 9 20 0.5
Electrochemical, existing 0 0 0 30 1
Other, fossil, existing 0 0 0 30 1
Other, biomass, existing 0 0 0 30 1
Other, electricity, existing 0 0 0 30 1
Other, heat, existing 0 0 0 30 1

Note: Cost unit is US$ GJ-1, which is measured as cost per energy service or useful energy.

Technological parameter assumptions on passenger transport sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Efficiency (MJ km -1)
  2010 2030 2050    
LDV, conventional 18 18 18 12 3.5
LDV, new 20 20 20 12 3.6
LDV, high-eff Lv1 21 21 21 12 3
LDV, high-eff Lv2 22 22 21 12 2.6
LDV, high-eff Lv3 22 22 22 12 2.5
LDV, HEV 23 23 23 12 2.1
LDV, PHEV 27 23 23 12 1.8
LDV, BEV 56 27 26 12 1.1
LDV, FCEV 43 28 25 12 1.4
Bus, conventional 130 130 130 15 10.1
Bus, new 150 150 150 15 8.9
Bus, high-eff 150 150 150 15 8
Bus, HEV 197 180 179 15 7.6
Bus, BEV 630 275 265 15 7
Bus, FCEV 272 200 186 15 7.2
Rail, electricity, conventional 14000 14000 14000 20 0.3
Rail, electricity, new 14000 14000 14000 20 0.2
Rail, electricity, high-eff 15000 15000 15000 20 0.2
Rail, other, conventional 14000 14000 14000 20 0.3
Rail, other, new 14000 14000 14000 20 0.2
Rail, other, high-eff 15000 15000 15000 20 0.2
Air, conventional 125000 125000 125000 30 2.6
Air, new 150000 150000 150000 30 2.5
Air, high-eff 190000 200000 213333 30 1.7

Note: Cost unit is 1000 US$ vehicle-1. Energy efficiency unit for non-road modes is MJ pkm-1.

Technological parameter assumptions on freight transport sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Efficiency (MJ km -1)
  2010 2030 2050    
Small truck, conventional 34 34 34 15 9.6
Small truck, new 37 37 37 15 8.5
Small truck, high-eff 37 37 37 15 8.2
Small truck, HEV 56 49 48 15 6.5
Small truck, NGV 58 58 58 15 8.5
Small truck, BEV 175 69 66 15 3.7
Small truck, FCEV 135 76 64 15 5.7
Large truck, conventional 100 100 100 15 14
Large truck, new 110 110 110 15 12.3
Large truck, high-eff 127 127 127 15 12
Large truck, NGV 187 187 187 15 12.3
Large truck, HEV 128 114 113 15 9.4
Large truck, BEV 1248 360 335 15 9
Large truck, FCEV 404 208 174 15 10
Rail, electricity, conventional 14000 14000 14000 20 0.4
Rail, electricity, new 15000 15000 15000 20 0.3
Rail, other, conventional 14000 14000 14000 20 0.4
Ship, existing 8050 8050 8050 20 1
Ship, high-eff 22344 22344 22344 20 0.5

Note: Cost unit is 1000 US$ vehicle-1 for road and rail, 1000 US$ GJ-1 for ship, respectively. Energy efficiency unit for non-road modes is MJ tkm-1.

Technological parameter assumptions on residential sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Efficiency
  2010 2030 2050    
Space heating, coal stove 260 260 260 15 0.75
Space heating, oil stove 203 203 203 15 0.75
Space heating, gas stove 182 182 182 15 0.9
Space heating, district heating 350 350 350 15 0.9
Space heating, geothermal 308 308 308 15 1
Space heating, air coditioner, conventional 308 273 202 15 3.56
Space heating, air coditioner, high-eff 323 286 212 15 4.2
Space heating, air coditioner, BAT 339 300 222 15 5.22
Space heating, biomass stove 350 350 350 15 0.7
Space cooling, air coditioner, conventional 308 273 202 15 3.56
Space cooling, air coditioner, high-eff 323 286 212 15 4.2
Space cooling, air coditioner, BAT 339 300 222 15 5.22
Water heating, coal, conventional 199 199 199 15 0.7
Water heating, coal, high-eff 317 317 317 15 0.8
Water heating, oil, conventional 119 119 119 15 0.7
Water heating, oil, high-eff 190 190 190 15 0.8
Water heating, gas, conventional 119 119 119 15 0.8
Water heating, gas, high-eff 190 190 190 15 0.9
Water heating, electric heating 79 79 79 15 0.9
Water heating, heat pump, conventional 353 301 214 15 4
Water heating, heat pump, efficient 392 334 238 15 5
Water heating, heat pump, high-eff 431 367 261 15 5.5
Water heating, solar thermal 696 696 696 15 1
Water heating, biomass 292 292 292 15 0.8
Water heating, fuel cell 1908 509 339 15 0.77
Cooking, coal, conventional 849 849 849 15 0.3
Cooking, coal, efficient 1431 1431 1431 15 0.37
Cooking, oil, conventional 564 564 564 15 0.4
Cooking, oil, efficient 951 951 951 15 0.5
Cooking, gas, conventional 564 564 564 15 0.4
Cooking, gas, efficient 951 951 951 15 0.5
Cooking, electric heating 611 611 611 15 0.72
Cooking, IH heater 696 696 696 15 1.19
Cooking, biomass, conventional 849 849 849 15 0.2
Cooking, biomass, efficient 1905 1905 1905 15 0.4
Incandescent lamp 5 5 5 2 1
Fluorescent lamp 42 42 42 4 4.5
LED lamp, conventional 105 105 105 8 6.07
LED lamp, efficient 210 210 210 8 10.71
LED lamp, more efficient 263 263 263 8 14.29
Kerosene lamp 5 5 5 2 0.5
Other appliances, conventional 478 478 478 10 0.8
Other appliances, efficient 521 521 521 10 1
Other appliances, high-eff 573 573 573 10 1.1
Other appliances, advanced 611 611 611 10 1.2

Note: Cost unit is US$ GJ-1, which is measured as cost per energy service or useful energy. Efficiency for thermal insulation measures relative efficiency improvement where insulation Lv5 equals 1.

Technological parameter assumptions on commercial sector.
  Initial cost     Lifetime (year) Efficiency
  2010 2030 2050    
Space heating, coal 240 240 240 15 0.75
Space heating, oil 140 140 140 15 0.75
Space heating, gas 140 140 140 15 0.9
Space heating, district heating 374 374 374 15 0.9
Space heating, geothermal 374 374 374 15 1
Space heating, air coditioner, conventional 231 204 151 15 3.56
Space heating, air coditioner, efficient 243 215 159 15 4.2
Space heating, air coditioner, high-eff 254 225 167 15 5.22
Space heating, biomass 525 525 525 15 0.7
Space cooling, gas HP, conventional 490 490 490 15 1.25
Space cooling, gas HP, efficient 490 490 490 15 1.35
Space cooling, air coditioner, conventional 308 273 202 15 3.56
Space cooling, air coditioner, efficient 323 286 212 15 4.2
Space cooling, air coditioner, high-eff 339 300 222 15 5.22
Water heaging, coal, conventional 209 209 209 15 0.71
Water heaging, coal, efficient 275 275 275 15 0.78
Water heaging, oil, conventional 146 146 146 15 0.76
Water heaging, oil, efficient 192 192 192 15 0.87
Water heaging, gas, conventional 146 146 146 15 0.76
Water heaging, gas, efficient 192 192 192 15 0.87
Water heaging, electric heating 112 112 112 15 0.9
Water heaging, heat pump, conventional 441 376 267 15 4
Water heaging, heat pump, efficienty 490 418 297 15 5
Water heaging, heat pump, high-eff 539 459 327 15 5.5
Water heaging, solar thermal water heater 1403 1403 1403 15 1
Water heaging, biomass-fired water heater 385 385 385 15 0.7
Water heaging, fuel cell water heater 1931 515 343 15 0.77
Cooking, coal, conventional 88 88 88 15 0.3
Cooking, coal, efficient 149 149 149 15 0.37
Cooking, oil, conventional 59 59 59 15 0.4
Cooking, oil, efficient 99 99 99 15 0.5
Cooking, gas, conventional 59 59 59 15 0.4
Cooking, gas, efficient 99 99 99 15 0.5
Cooking, electric heating 58 58 58 15 0.7
Cooking, IH heater 61 61 61 15 0.8
Cooking, biomass 88 88 88 15 0.2
Incandescent lamp 5 5 5 2 1
fluorescent lamp 42 42 42 4 4.5
LED lamp, conventional 105 105 105 8 6.07
LED lamp, efficient 210 210 210 8 10.71
LED lamp, more efficient 263 263 263 8 14.29
Kerosene lamp 5 5 5 2 0.5
Other appliances, old type 454 454 454 10 0.72
Other appliances, conventional type 478 478 478 10 0.8
Other appliances, efficient type 521 521 521 10 1
Other appliances, best available technology 573 573 573 10 1.1
Other appliances, advanced technology 611 611 611 10 1.2

Note: Cost unit is US$ GJ-1, which is measured as cost per energy service or useful energy. Efficiency for thermal insulation measures relative efficiency improvement where insulation Lv5 equals 1.

Supplementary data on energy service estimation

Industry

Regression results for cement production. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Region codes denote the dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -303.54 -13.29 (***)
LGDPP 228.73 27.2 (***)
AUS -157.42 -9.02 (***)
CAN -136.86 -8.05 (***)
CHN 641.77 27.79 (***)
IDN 250.91 11.89 (***)
IND 454.4 16.13 (***)
JPN 109.01 6.24 (***)
KOR 801.22 54.88 (***)
MEX 117.5 7.82 (***)
MYS 419.52 26.52 (***)
NZL -225.83 -14.18 (***)
RUS 129 7.89 (***)
THA 471.79 25.52 (***)
TUR 410.6 26.92 (***)
USA -245.99 -14.07 (***)
VNM 540.48 18.62 (***)
XAF 369.57 13.7 (***)
XCS 234.81 10.04 (***)
XE10 158.85 10.61 (***)
XE3 260.68 15.69 (***)
XEA 1006.35 25.06 (***)
XEEI 298.84 14.32 (***)
XENI 285.96 13.07 (***)
XEWI -177.73 -8.83 (***)
XLM 131.12 7.98 (***)
XME 268.67 17.6 (***)
XNF 432.41 21.03 (***)
XOC 184.89 8.5 (***)
XSA 439.23 15.15 (***)
XSE 255.51 11.65 (***)
ZAF 84.73 5.28 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.949

Regression results on other industry energy service demand. Region codes denote the dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept 1.99 155.73 (***)
LVA_INDP 0.4 40.76 (***)
AUS 0.56 4.23 (***)
CAN 0.75 4.76 (***)
IDN -0.43 -10.37 (***)
IND -0.5 -18.38 (***)
MYS 0.56 4.76 (***)
NZL 0.88 2.96 (**)
RUS 0.77 15.39 (***)
USA 0.53 11.91 (***)
XAF -1.21 -39.42 (***)
XCS 0.72 9.26 (***)
XE10 0.31 4.48 (***)
XEA 1.78 14.83 (***)
XEEI 0.83 10.49 (***)
XME 0.51 11.39 (***)
XOC 0.68 3.47 (***)
XSA -0.72 -17.75 (***)
XSE -1.13 -22.88 (***)
ZAF 0.42 4.85 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.954

Transport

Regression results for total passenger transport demand. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -1.07 -43.22 (***)
LGDPP 0.85 70.44 (***)
AUS 0.92 22.29 (***)
BRA 0.23 6.29 (***)
CAN 0.86 20.69 (***)
IDN 0.4 11.36 (***)
JPN 0.43 10.46 (***)
KOR 0.42 10.96 (***)
MYS 0.56 15.11 (***)
NZL 0.97 24.18 (***)
RUS 0.35 9.1 (***)
THA 0.42 11.71 (***)
TUR -0.27 -7.32 (***)
USA 1.06 24.65 (***)
VNM -0.24 -6.59 (***)
XE10 0.4 10.31 (***)
XE15 0.49 11.89 (***)
XE3 0.31 8.26 (***)
XEA 0.41 8.98 (***)
XEEI 0.5 13.7 (***)
XENI 0.19 5.51 (***)
XEWI -0.72 -16.41 (***)
XLM 0.18 4.99 (***)
XNF -0.19 -5.36 (***)
XOC 0.34 9.1 (***)
ZAF 0.48 13.37 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.976

Regression results for the passenger transport modal share of private cars. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -0.32 -3.67 (***)
LGDPP 0.97 29.38 (***)
BRA 1.69 19.56 (***)
CAN 2.29 24.1 (***)
CHN -1.95 -21.14 (***)
IDN -0.43 -4.81 (***)
IND -1.95 -19.79 (***)
JPN -2.04 -21.75 (***)
KOR -1.47 -16.47 (***)
MEX 3.35 38.32 (***)
MYS 2.24 25.66 (***)
NZL 1.7 18.3 (***)
RUS -1.44 -15.89 (***)
USA 3.06 31.1 (***)
XAF 2.33 22.81 (***)
XE10 -0.62 -6.79 (***)
XE15 -0.91 -9.52 (***)
XE3 -0.68 -7.6 (***)
XEA 0.69 5.17 (***)
XEEI -1.47 -16.35 (***)
XENI 1.15 12.95 (***)
XEWI -0.96 -9.49 (***)
XLM 2.15 24.56 (***)
XME 0.86 9.88 (***)
XNF -0.76 -8.71 (***)
XSA -0.87 -8.85 (***)
XSE 0.64 7.07 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.953

Regression results for the passenger transport modal share of buses. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept 0.53 4.15 (***)
LGDPP 0.42 8.82 (***)
AUS -1.42 -12.68 (***)
BRA 1.87 19.5 (***)
CAN 0.69 6.17 (***)
CHN -0.73 -6.94 (***)
IDN 1.7 17.05 (***)
IND -0.71 -6.15 (***)
JPN -3.05 -27.74 (***)
KOR -0.77 -7.61 (***)
MEX 3.02 30.95 (***)
MYS 2.08 21.29 (***)
NZL 0.49 4.53 (***)
RUS -2.39 -23.61 (***)
THA 0.92 9.6 (***)
TUR 0.85 8.7 (***)
USA 1.09 9.26 (***)
VNM 1.54 13.67 (***)
XAF 3.27 26.71 (***)
XCS -0.86 -8.38 (***)
XE10 -1.1 -10.81 (***)
XE15 -1.97 -17.54 (***)
XE3 -0.97 -9.78 (***)
XEA 1.19 6.89 (***)
XEEI -1.9 -19.25 (***)
XEWI -1.75 -14.38 (***)
XLM 2.22 22.72 (***)
XME 0.52 5.32 (***)
XNF -1.18 -12.04 (***)
XSA 0.69 5.98 (***)
XSE 0.41 3.94 (***)
ZAF 0.32 3.37 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.929

Regression results for the passenger transport modal share of domestic aviation. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -1.81 -30.76 (***)
LGDPP 0.55 23.16 (***)
AUS 0.8 7.83 (***)
BRA 1.6 16.72 (***)
CAN 2.69 26.2 (***)
CHN -0.65 -6.79 (***)
IND -1.9 -19.42 (***)
JPN -1.6 -15.67 (***)
KOR -1.51 -15.3 (***)
MEX 3.51 36.19 (***)
MYS 2.15 22.19 (***)
NZL 2.25 22.2 (***)
RUS -1.12 -11.16 (***)
THA -0.44 -4.58 (***)
TUR -0.58 -5.93 (***)
USA 4.09 39.02 (***)
VNM 0.72 7.42 (***)
XAF 0.83 8.33 (***)
XCS -1.36 -13.77 (***)
XE10 -2.99 -29.54 (***)
XE15 -1.7 -16.56 (***)
XE3 -3.94 -39.42 (***)
XEEI -3.23 -32.68 (***)
XLM 1.5 15.76 (***)
XME 0.5 5.16 (***)
XNF -1.97 -20.73 (***)
XSA -1.5 -15.32 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.952

Regression results for the passenger transport modal share of international aviation. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -2.95 -25.92 (***)
LGDPP 1.09 24.52 (***)
AUS 0.56 5.09 (***)
BRA 1.43 15.1 (***)
CAN 2.18 19.74 (***)
CHN -0.5 -4.91 (***)
IND -1.2 -10.74 (***)
JPN -2.06 -18.98 (***)
MEX 2.66 27.44 (***)
MYS 3.35 34.66 (***)
NZL 2.82 26.48 (***)
RUS -2.19 -21.68 (***)
THA 1.71 18.04 (***)
TUR 0.63 6.54 (***)
USA 2.2 18.96 (***)
VNM 1.37 12.62 (***)
XAF 3.86 32.95 (***)
XE10 -1.19 -11.72 (***)
XE15 -0.66 -5.92 (***)
XE3 -1.43 -14.4 (***)
XEA 2.4 14.69 (***)
XEEI -2.99 -30.48 (***)
XENI 1.61 16.56 (***)
XEWI -0.81 -6.75 (***)
XLM 2.7 28.16 (***)
XME 1.87 19.45 (***)
XSA 1.28 11.49 (***)
XSE 3.41 33.86 (***)
ZAF 0.73 7.68 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.947

Regression results for total freight transport demand for road and rail. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -0.84 -13.42 (***)
LGDPP 0.65 31.09 (***)
AUS 0.84 18.32 (***)
BRA 0.33 7.51 (***)
CAN 1.48 32.4 (***)
CHN 0.23 4.38 (***)
IDN -0.41 -8.47 (***)
IND -0.34 -6 (***)
JPN -0.73 -16.15 (***)
MYS 0.39 9.02 (***)
NZL 0.35 7.85 (***)
RUS 1.12 25.28 (***)
THA 0.25 5.57 (***)
TUR -0.3 -6.94 (***)
USA 0.94 19.79 (***)
VNM -0.35 -6.35 (***)
XAF -0.88 -14.54 (***)
XCS 0.47 9.45 (***)
XE10 0.26 5.79 (***)
XEA 0.33 3.93 (***)
XEEI 0.95 20.52 (***)
XENI -0.56 -11.83 (***)
XEWI -0.99 -20.19 (***)
XME 0.22 5.13 (***)
XNF -0.45 -9.8 (***)
XOC -0.34 -6.06 (***)
XSA -0.98 -17.06 (***)
XSE -0.94 -18.69 (***)
ZAF 0.75 16.94 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.965

Regression results for the freight transport modal share of road transport. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept 1.01 10.07 (***)
LGDPP 0.48 14.79 (***)
AUS -2.56 -42.4 (***)
BRA -1.05 -18.12 (***)
CAN -2.91 -48.23 (***)
CHN -1.96 -26.68 (***)
IDN 1.76 26.47 (***)
IND -1.41 -16.88 (***)
JPN -0.32 -5.43 (***)
MEX -0.89 -15.73 (***)
MYS 2.27 40.13 (***)
NZL -1.07 -18.17 (***)
RUS -4.23 -72.9 (***)
THA 1.61 27.17 (***)
USA -3.11 -48.87 (***)
VNM 1.57 19.49 (***)
XAF 1.03 11.59 (***)
XCS -3.37 -49.38 (***)
XE10 -2.21 -38.06 (***)
XE15 -1.07 -17.63 (***)
XE3 -2.27 -38.79 (***)
XEA -1.9 -14.77 (***)
XEEI -3.75 -60.56 (***)
XENI -1.7 -25.81 (***)
XEWI -0.8 -12.14 (***)
XLM 1.06 16.79 (***)
XME 0.9 15.83 (***)
XNF 0.33 5.17 (***)
XSA 1.18 14.12 (***)
XSE 0.89 12.53 (***)
ZAF -1.84 -31.01 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.979

Regression results for freight domestic navigation transport demand. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -3.14 -6.49 (***)
LGDP 0.56 14.96 (***)
AUS 1.82 21.19 (***)
BRA 2.08 20.21 (***)
CAN 2.75 29.99 (***)
CHN 3.53 27.69 (***)
IDN 2.65 28.04 (***)
IND 1.19 10.73 (***)
JPN 2.92 24.26 (***)
KOR 3.47 38.4 (***)
MEX 1.75 17.92 (***)
NZL 1.21 12.81 (***)
RUS 1.97 18.03 (***)
THA 0.41 4.82 (***)
TUR 1.2 13.26 (***)
USA 2.28 14.85 (***)
XAF 0.74 7.71 (***)
XCS -2.55 -29.69 (***)
XE10 -1.37 -14.08 (***)
XE15 2.6 16.67 (***)
XE3 0.7 8.19 (***)
XEEI 0.48 5.55 (***)
XEWI 2.27 26.67 (***)
XLM 2.12 21.74 (***)
XNF 2.14 23.58 (***)
XOC 1.86 14.4 (***)
XSA 0.88 9.93 (***)
XSE 2.32 27.02 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.961

Regression results for freight international navigation transport demand. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Variable Coefficient t-value
Intercept -1.35 -5.29 (***)
LGDP 0.58 30.71 (***)
BRA 0.57 7.38 (***)
CHN 1.36 16.12 (***)
IDN -1.5 -20.02 (***)
IND -1.16 -14.6 (***)
JPN 0.93 11.34 (***)
KOR 2.03 27.38 (***)
MEX -0.42 -5.5 (***)
MYS -1.29 -17.38 (***)
NZL 0.18 2.28 (*)
THA 0.39 5.31 (***)
TUR -0.84 -11.28 (***)
USA 1.85 19.68 (***)
XE15 2.34 24.6 (***)
XE3 -1.18 -15.46 (***)
XENI 1.55 20.6 (***)
XLM 1.35 17.74 (***)
XME 2.39 30.26 (***)
XNF 0.91 12.2 (***)
XSA -0.92 -12.51 (***)
XSE 3.36 45.66 (***)
ZAF 1.57 21.29 (***)

Adjusted \(R^2\) = 0.955

Buildings

Regression results for residential energy service demand. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Service Variable Coefficient t-value Adjusted \(R^2\)
Space heating Intercept 1.29 3.32 (***) 0.866
  LGDPP 0.31 3.13 (**)  
  LHDD 1.1 18.68 (***)  
  CAN -0.71 -5.03 (***)  
  JPN -1.55 -15.56 (***)  
  KOR -1.27 -9.53 (***)  
  NZL -1.44 -7.62 (***)  
  TUR -1.26 -8.53 (***)  
  USA -0.72 -7.09 (***)  
  XE10 -0.78 -5.07 (***)  
  XE15 -0.65 -6.15 (***)  
  XEEI -0.89 -3.68 (***)  
  XEWI -0.75 -4.53 (***)  
Space cooling Intercept -3.62 -4.45 (***) 0.989
  LGDPP 0.89 4.13 (***)  
  LCDD 0.59 9.15 (***)  
  CAN 0.81 9.27 (***)  
  KOR -0.77 -8.14 (***)  
  NZL -3.04 -26.85 (***)  
  USA 1.23 15.57 (***)  
Water heating Intercept -1.28 -5.4 (***) 0.884
  LGDPP 0.68 10.31 (***)  
  HDD 0.2 16.45 (***)  
  KOR -0.23 -5.11 (***)  
  TUR -0.91 -16.2 (***)  
  USA -0.12 -3.89 (***)  
  XE10 -0.22 -3.9 (***)  
  XE15 -0.56 -24.31 (***)  
  XEWI -0.78 -8.08 (***)  
Other Appliances Intercept -0.99 -3.85 (***) 0.97
  LGDPP 0.72 10.64 (***)  
  BRA -0.67 -8.1 (***)  
  KOR -0.42 -8.23 (***)  
  TUR -0.83 -12.67 (***)  
  USA 0.44 12.33 (***)  
  XE10 -0.58 -8.11 (***)  
  XE15 -0.44 -13.67 (***)  
  XEWI -0.5 -5.48 (***)  
  XNF -0.54 -3.81 (***)  
Cooking Intercept -0.43 -7.22 (***) 0.914
  LPOP 1.13 64.03 (***)  
  BRA 0.82 6.57 (***)  
  CAN 0.45 4.36 (***)  
  XE10 0.59 9.49 (***)  
  XEEI 0.77 5.69 (***)  
  XNF 1.07 8.93 (***)  
Regression results for commercial energy service demand. Region codes are dummy variables for each region. Numbers in parenthesis indicates t-value. Asterisks indicate p-value ranges at \(p \le 0.001 (***)\), \(p \le 0.01 (**)\), \(p \le 0.05 (*)\), \(p \le 0.1 ( )\).
Service Variable Coefficient t-value Adjusted \(R^2\)
Space heating Intercept -2.82 -7.76 (***) 0.861
  LGDPP 1.16 10.59 (***)  
  LHDD 0.76 16.52 (***)  
  JPN -0.85 -12.41 (***)  
  NZL -0.36 -5.14 (***)  
  USA -0.64 -6.21 (***)  
  XE15 -0.55 -11.55 (***)  
  XEWI -0.59 -6.92 (***)  
Space cooling Intercept -1.34 -2.97 (**) 0.95
  LGDPP 0.52 4.49 (***)  
  LCDD 0.13 3.49 (***)  
  KOR 0.71 10.23 (***)  
  NZL -0.81 -14.37 (***)  
Other services Intercept -1.75 -14.09 (***) 0.835
  LGDPP 1.06 28.51 (***)  
  USA 0.42 4.66 (***)  
  XE15 -0.46 -11.65 (***)  
  XEWI -0.81 -11.78 (***)